Alternative Engagement Rings

Filter

      Alternative engagement rings offer a unique and personalized approach to symbolizing your commitment. They provide an opportunity to deviate from traditional diamond-centered designs and explore a variety of other gemstones, styles, and materials. Learn more about alternative engagement rings, and find the perfect gemstone ring for your loved one in our extensive yet carefully curated collection.

      About Alternative Engagement Rings

      Alternative engagement rings offer a departure from classic diamond-centered designs, providing a unique and personalized way to symbolize your commitment. These rings allow you to explore various gemstones to create a one-of-a-kind piece that reflects your individuality and love story.

      Alternative Engagement Ring Designs

      Alternative engagement ring designs offer a departure from traditional styles, allowing you to embrace unique and personalized options that reflect your individuality and style.

      • Stunning Gemstones - Gemstones possess a captivating beauty that can captivate and inspire. These stunning gemstones offer an array of captivating colors and characteristics, each possessing its unique allure.
      • Conflict Free - Vintage gemstone rings involve the use of previously mined gemstones and metals. By opting for a vintage ring, you are promoting the reuse of these materials instead of supporting new mining activities, which can have negative environmental and social impacts.
      • Versatility - Gemstones offer a remarkable versatility that allows them to be incorporated into various types of jewelry and designs.
      • Classic Eras - Many designs from the Victorian and Art Deco era feature bold colored gemstones like rubies, sapphires, emeralds, and aquamarine, allowing for even more distinction and personalization in each ring.

      Find The Perfect Engagement Ring

      These precious pieces are prized not only for their beauty but also for their exquisite attention to detail. If you’re looking for a gemstone ring with a sense of glamour, sophistication and vintage charm, explore our collection of alternative engagement rings today.

      215 products

      215 products

      Sold Out
      1.80 Ct Vintage Peridot and Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      SOLD SOLD 1.80 Ct Vintage Peridot and Round Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,189.00
      Victorian Style 1.25 Carat Round Green Tourmaline Engagement Ring
      $1,850.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Square Cut Emerald Rose Cut & Pearl Halo Engagement Ring
      SOLD SOLD Victorian Square Cut Emerald Rose Cut & Pearl Halo Engagement Ring
      $650.00
      Sold Out
      Art Deco Bezel Set Old European Cut Diamond & Emerald Engagment Ring
      SOLD ON LAYAWAY SOLD Art Deco Bezel Set Old European Cut Diamond & Emerald Engagment Ring
      $1,600.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Opal and Pearl Engagement Ring
      Victorian Opal and Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Sapphire and Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring Circa 1900's
      SOLD SOLD SOLD Victorian Sapphire and Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring Circa 1900s
      $3,800.00
      Vintage Style Emerald Cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      Vintage Style Emerald Cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      $1,850.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Opal and Rose Cut Diamond Wedding Ring
      SOLD SOLD SOLD Victorian Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Wedding Ring
      $1,450.00
      Sold Out
      Emerald & European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1.06 CT Columbian AGL
      SOLD SOLD SOLD Emerald & European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1.06 CT Columbian AGL
      $7,650.00
      Sold Out
      Dainty Victorian Opal & Seed Pearl Wedding Ring
      $1,375.00
      Sold Out
      Dainty Victorian Emerald & Pearl Wedding Ring
      Dainty Victorian Emerald & Pearl Wedding Ring
      $1,350.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Rectangular Cut Garnet & Diamond Engagement Ring
      Victorian Rectangular Cut Garnet & Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,750.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Opal Transitional Cut Diamond & Pearl Engagement Ring
      Victorian Opal Transitional Cut Diamond & Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Moonstone & Rose Cut Diamond Ring
      Victorian Moonstone & Rose Cut Diamond Ring
      $1,750.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Round Cut Garnet and Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Victorian Round Cut Garnet & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,650.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Garnet Diamond & Pearl Engagement Ring
      Victorian Garnet Diamond & Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian 2 Stone Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Victorian 2 Stone Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Art Deco Round Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Old Modified Round Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      $2,500.00
      Sold Out
      Art Deco Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      $3,250.00
      Sold Out
      Art Deco Diamond Engagement Ring with Sapphire Side Stones
      Art Deco Diamond Engagement Ring with Sapphire Side Stones
      $4,500.00
      Art Deco Style Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Style Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring
      $2,250.00
      Delicate Victorian Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Delicate Victorian Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Opal and Garnet Halo Engagement Ring
      Vintage Opal and Garnet Halo Engagement Ring
      $1,375.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Opal and Rose Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring
      Victorian Opal and Rose Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Sold Out
      Victorian Purple Garnet and Pearl Engagement Ring
      Victorian Purple Garnet and Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Vintage Style Burma Ruby Halo Engagement Ring .78 CT
      Vintage Style Burma Ruby Halo Engagement Ring .78 CT
      $5,500.00
      Sold Out
      Art Deco Asscher Cut Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Asscher Cut Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring
      $4,000.00
      Sold Out
      Thin Filigree Band Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring
      Thin Filigree Band Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring
      $4,500.00
      Delicate Victorian Turquoise and Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,675.00
      1.50 Carat Victorian Emerald Cut Amethyst Engagement Ring Circa 1900's
      $1,550.00
      Art Deco Aquamarine Split Shank Engagement Ring with Navette Side Stones
      $3,250.00
      Antique Twin Stone Synthetic Ruby Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Exquisite Victorian Turquoise and Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,675.00
      Delicate Victorian Opal & Seed Pearl Wedding Ring
      Delicate Victorian Opal & Seed Pearl Wedding Ring
      $1,550.00
      Art Deco Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring 1.16 Ct GIA J/SI1
      Art Deco Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring 1.16 Ct GIA J/SI1
      $12,000.00
      Vintage Emerald Cut Emerald Engagement Ring with Side Stones
      $3,250.00
      Victorian Ruby and Old Mine Cut Diamond Wedding Ring
      $2,750.00
      Antique 14 Kt Two Tone Square Cut Sapphire Engagement Ring with Side Stones
      Antique 14 Kt Two Tone Square Cut Sapphire Engagement Ring with Side Stones
      $1,350.00
      Art Deco Emerald Cut Amethyst Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.25 Ct
      $1,950.00
      Victorian Rectangular Cut Amethyst Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.50 Ct
      Victorian Rectangular Cut Amethyst Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.50 Ct
      $2,250.00
      1.00 Carat Art Deco Green Onyx & Round Diamond Engagement Ring
      1.00 Carat Art Deco Green Onyx & Round Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,650.00
      2.00 Carat Art Deco Moval Garnet Engagement Ring
      $1,850.00
      1970s Vintage Rectangular Cut Topaz Engagement Ring 2.50 Ct
      1970s Vintage Rectangular Cut Topaz Engagement Ring 2.50 Ct
      $2,850.00
      Intricate Art Deco Diamond Engagement Ring with Sapphire Side Stones .58 Ct GIA G/SI1
      $3,550.00
      Vintage 1940s 4 Row Gemstone Rosy Yellow Gold Stacking Band
      Vintage 1940s 4 Row Gemstone Rosy Yellow Gold Stacking Band
      $1,850.00
      Victorian Garnet Starburst Wedding Rings Circa 1900's
      Victorian Garnet Starburst Wedding Ring Circa 1900's
      $1,300.00
      Art Deco Emerald Cut Amethyst Engagement Ring 3.90 Carat
      Art Deco Emerald Cut Amethyst Engagement Ring 3.90 Carat
      $2,750.00
      Art Deco 2.00 Carat Oval Cut Citrine Engagement Ring Circa 1930's
      Art Deco 2.00 Carat Oval Cut Citrine Engagement Ring Circa 1930's
      $1,850.00
      Dainty Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond and Sapphire Wedding Band Circa 1900's
      Dainty Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond and Sapphire Wedding Band Circa 1900's
      $1,500.00
      Art Deco Rectangular Cut Citrine Engagement Ring Circa 1930's
      Art Deco Rectangular Cut Citrine Engagement Ring Circa 1930's
      $1,850.00
      Victorian Bezel Set Blue Zircon Solitaire Engagement Ring Circa 1940's
      Victorian Bezel Set Blue Zircon Solitaire Engagement Ring Circa 1940's
      $1,500.00
      Victorian Red Spinel and Old Mine Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring Circa 1900's
      Victorian Red Spinel and Old Mine Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring Circa 1900's
      $3,000.00
      Victorian East-West Oval Peridot and Seed Pearl Engagement Ring Circa 1900's
      Victorian East-West Oval Peridot and Seed Pearl Engagement Ring Circa 1900's
      $1,500.00
      Old Mine Cut Champagne Diamond & Demantoid Garnet Engagement Ring
      Old Mine Cut Champagne Diamond & Demantoid Garnet Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Retro Vintage 1940's Cushion Cut Aquamarine Ring w/ Diamonds 14K 3.90 Ct
      Retro Vintage 1940s Cushion Cut Aquamarine Ring w/ Diamonds 14K 3.90 Ct
      $3,750.00
      Antique Twin Stone Old Mine Cut Diamond & Garnet Engagement Ring 19 Kt Rose Gold
      Antique Twin Stone Old Mine Cut Diamond & Garnet Engagement Ring 19 Kt Rose Gold
      $1,500.00
      Art Deco Pearl and Onyx Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Pearl and Onyx Engagement Ring
      $2,500.00
      Art Deco Old Mine Cut Diamond & Square Cut Sapphire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Old Mine Cut Diamond & Square Cut Sapphire Engagement Ring
      $4,000.00
      Victorian Opal & Seed Pearl Gemstone Ring
      Victorian Opal & Seed Pearl Gemstone Ring
      $1,500.00
      Sold Out
      Art Deco 3.50 ct Aquamarine & Single Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Art Deco 3.50 ct Aquamarine & Single Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Victorian Almandine Garnet and White Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      Victorian Almandine Garnet and White Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Vintage Old Mine Cut Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring in Platinum
      Vintage Old Mine Cut Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring in Platinum
      $3,550.00
      Vintage Turquoise Starburst Engagement Ring
      Vintage Turquoise Starburst Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Antique 1.50 Ct Emerald Cut Citrine Gemstone Engagement Ring
      Antique 1.50 Ct Emerald Cut Citrine Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $2,050.00
      Art Deco Pearl & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Pearl & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,650.00
      Dainty Victorian Sapphire and Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Dainty Victorian Sapphire and Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,350.00
      Victorian Sapphire and North South Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Victorian Sapphire & North South Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond and Ruby Wedding Ring
      Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond and Ruby Wedding Ring
      $1,350.00
      Art Deco Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring .25 Ct
      Art Deco Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring .25 Ct
      $1,650.00
      Victorian North-South Sapphire and Pearl Engagement Ring with Filigree
      Victorian North-South Sapphire and Pearl Engagement Ring with Filigree
      $1,500.00
      Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond and Sapphire Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Victorian Ceylon Oval Cut Sapphire and Diamond Engagement Ring .30 Carat
      $2,250.00
      Victorian Synthetic Ruby & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Victorian Synthetic Ruby & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Victorian Ceylon Sapphire Diamond & Pearl Engagement Ring .35 Ct
      $2,250.00
      Rare Victorian Pink Opal Alexandrite and Pearl Wedding Ring
      Rare Victorian Pink Opal Alexandrite and Pearl Wedding Ring
      $2,050.00
      Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Wedding Ring
      Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Wedding Ring
      $2,500.00
      Vintage Square Cut Colombian Emerald & Straight Baguette Diamond Ring
      Vintage Square Cut Colombian Emerald & Straight Baguette Diamond Ring
      $4,250.00
      Antique Old Mine Diamond Engagement Ring with Square Cut Sapphires
      $3,250.00
      Sweet Victorian Turquoise and Pearl Engagement Ring
      Sweet Victorian Turquoise and Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,850.00
      Sold Out
      Delicate Victorian Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring
      Delicate Victorian Opal & Rose Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring
      $2,138.00