Vintage Engagement Rings Under $5,000

Filter
      Filter By

      If you're looking for a breathtaking piece of jewelry with a fascinating history and undeniable elegance, you’ll find it within our curated collection of engagement rings under $5,000. Opulent but never overdesigned, these pieces feature time-honored styles that display a kind of craftsmanship that is rarely found in rings from the modern era.

      Read More
      1314 products

      1314 products

      Filter By
      1314 Products
      Availability Best Selling Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, new to old Date, old to new % Sale off
      Victorian Style 1.25 Carat Round Green Tourmaline Engagement Ring
      Victorian Style 1.25 Carat Round Green Tourmaline Engagement Ring
      $1,495.00
      Art Deco 3.07 CTW Style Citrine Solitaire Gemstone Engagement Ring
      Art Deco 3.07 CTW Style Citrine Solitaire Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $2,050.00
      .10 Ct Estate Contoured Diamond Stacking Band in 18K White Gold
      $1,350.00
      Vintage Style 1.19 CTW Emerald Cut Garnet Gemstone Engagement Ring
      Vintage Style 1.19 CTW Emerald Cut Garnet Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $1,650.00
      Victorian Style Two Tone Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring .50 Ct GIA H/SI2
      Victorian Style Two Tone Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring .51 Ct GIA G/VS1
      $2,950.00
      Estate Vintage Style Peridot and Pave Set Diamond Engagement Ring
      Estate Vintage Style Peridot and Pave Set Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Art Deco Style Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco Style Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Vintage Style Emerald Cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      Vintage Style Emerald Cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      $1,450.00
      Vintage Style 2.05 CTW Kite Shape Topaz Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $2,750.00
      Victorian Turquoise and Pearl Engagement Ring
      $1,675.00
      Victorian Turquoise Starburst Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      3.93 Carat Victorian Style Emerald Cut Citrine Engagement Ring
      3.93 Carat Victorian Style Emerald Cut Citrine Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Victorian Round Cut Garnet & Moonstone Engagement Ring
      Victorian Round Cut Garnet & Moonstone Engagement Ring
      $1,650.00
      Art Deco .61 CTW Old European Cut Platinum Antique Engagement Ring
      Art Deco .61 CTW Old European Cut Platinum Antique Engagement Ring
      $2,750.00
      Vintage Style Long Marquise Navette Diamond Engagement Ring .57 Carat GIA E/I1
      $2,550.00
      Victorian Style Round Aquamarine Halo Engagement Ring .75 Carat
      Victorian Style Round Aquamarine Halo Engagement Ring .85 Carat
      $1,850.00
      Art Deco 1.50 CTW Old Modified Round Aquamarine Engagement Ring
      $1,550.00
      Victorian Style Yellow Gold Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring .44 Ct GIA G/VS2
      Victorian Style Yellow Gold Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring .44 Ct GIA G/VS2
      $2,450.00
      Vintage Diamond Baguette Wedding Ring 1.00 Ct
      $3,250.00
      Antique 1940s Geometric Square Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Antique 1940s Geometric Square Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $2,550.00
      Vintage Rectangular Cut Aquamarine Ring with Baguette Diamonds
      Vintage Rectangular Cut Aquamarine Ring with Baguette Diamonds
      $1,650.00
      .30 Ct Diamond Contoured Round Wedding Band in 18K White Gold
      $1,350.00
      Delicate Prong Set 14 Kt Two Tone Gold and Diamond Wedding Band
      $1,150.00
      Mid-Century 1.00 CTW Diamond Ruby Halo Vintage Engagement Ring
      Mid-Century 1.00 CTW Diamond Ruby Halo Vintage Engagement Ring
      $2,500.00
      Antique Navette White Gold Wedding Band Signed Jabel
      $1,050.00
      Unique Edwardian .63 CTW European Cut Diamond Halo Vintage Engagement Ring
      Unique Edwardian .63 CTW European Cut Diamond Halo Vintage Engagement Ring
      $2,450.00
      Antique .20 CTW Old European Cut Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring with Filigree Engravings
      Antique .20 CTW Old European Cut Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,350.00
      Late Art Deco .10 Ct Two Tone Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,050.00
      Vintage .10 Ct Diamond Antique Dinner Ring Signed Jabel
      Vintage .10 Ct Diamond Antique Dinner Ring Signed Jabel
      $2,550.00
      Victorian .15 CTW 14 Karat Rose Gold Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      Victorian .15 CTW 14 Karat Rose Gold Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $995.00
      Stackable Garnet Wedding Band - Vintage Diamond Ring
      Stackable Garnet Wedding Band
      $1,250.00
      Art Deco .45 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Antique Engagement Ring with Milgrain
      $1,750.00
      Mid-Century .17 CTW Vintage 14/18 Karat Two Tone Diamond Three Stone Engagement Ring
      $1,050.00
      Art Deco .20 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring with Open Metal Work
      $1,500.00
      Dainty Antique .15 CTW Old Mine Cut 18 Karat White Gold Solitaire Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Late Edwardian .75 CTW Diamond Platinum Open Work Antique Dinner Ring
      Late Edwardian .75 CTW Diamond Platinum Open Work Antique Dinner Ring
      $3,250.00
      Victorian .08 CTW Old Mine Cut 10 Karat Rose Gold Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Petite Art Deco Single Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Art Deco .30 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond 14 Karat White Gold Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring
      $1,600.00
      Art Deco .57 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Vintage Engagement Ring
      $3,000.00
      Art Deco .35 CTW Old European Cut Solitaire 18 Karat White Gold Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,750.00
      Art Deco .18 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring
      Art Deco .18 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring
      $1,350.00
      Art Deco .80 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond 14 Karat White Gold Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring
      $3,050.00
      Art Deco .36 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Kt White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring with Side Tiered Stones
      Art Deco .36 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Kt White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring with Side Tiered Stones
      $1,750.00
      Art Deco .55 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Kt White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring Signed "Barth"
      Art Deco .55 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Kt White Gold Vintage Engagement Ring Signed "Barth"
      $2,850.00
      Vintage 2.14 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring with Clarity Enhancement
      Vintage 2.09 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring with Clarity Enhancement
      $2,900.00
      Vintage Style Lab Grown Old Mine Cushion Cut 18 Karat Yellow Gold Engagement Ring IGI E/VS1
      Vintage Style Lab Grown Old Mine Cushion Cut 18 Karat Yellow Gold Engagement Ring IGI E/VS1
      $4,000.00
      Lab Grown 3.08 CTW Cushion Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
      Lab Grown 3.08 CTW Cushion Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Art Deco .33 CTW Prong Set Old European Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring
      $1,750.00
      Antique Georgian 9 Kt Yellow Gold Pearl Onyx Enamel Mourning Ring
      Antique Georgian 9 Kt Yellow Gold Pearl Onyx Enamel Mourning Ring
      $2,500.00
      Victorian .70 CTW Opal & Mine Cut Diamond Antique Dinner Ring
      Victorian .70 CTW Opal & Mine Cut Diamond Antique Dinner Ring
      $2,350.00
      Mid-Century 2.35 CTW Moonstone Round Cut Diamond Vintage Cocktail Ring Signed Ruser
      Mid-Century 2.35 CTW Moonstone Round Cut Diamond Vintage Cocktail Ring Signed Ruser
      $3,250.00
      Victorian .80 CTW Burma Ruby Mine Cut Diamond Halo Antique Engagement Ring
      Victorian .80 CTW Burma Ruby Mine Cut Diamond Halo Antique Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Victorian .35 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Halo Antique Engagement Ring
      Victorian .35 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Halo Antique Engagement Ring
      $2,250.00
      Victorian 1.20 CTW Burma Oval Cut Ruby Mine Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Victorian Coral and Rose Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $2,250.00
      Mid-Century .70 CTW Mine and Round Cut Diamond 14 Kt Vintage Cocktail Ring
      $2,250.00
      Mid-Century 1.10 CTW Platinum Kite Baguette Round Diamond Cocktail Ring
      Mid-Century 1.10 CTW Platinum Kite Baguette Round Diamond Cocktail Ring
      $3,500.00
      Mid-Century 3.90 CTW Opal Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      Mid-Century 3.90 CTW Opal Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $4,250.00
      Antique 1.30 CTW Synthetic Sapphire Rose Cut Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $1,750.00
      Art Deco .03 CTW 14 Karat White Gold Diamond Filigree Vintage Engagement Ring
      Art Deco .03 CTW 14 Karat White Gold Diamond Filigree Vintage Engagement Ring
      $995.00
      Mid-Century .61 CTW 14 Karat White Gold Marquise Cut Diamond Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring GIA D/SI1
      $1,850.00
      Antique 10.00 CTW Art Deco Aquamarine Solitaire Vintage Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $3,500.00
      Antique 1.20 CTW Art Deco Aquamarine Sapphire Gemstone Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Victorian .15 CTW 14 Karat Two tone Gold Old European Cut Solitaire Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      Victorian .15 CTW 14 Karat Two Tone Gold Old European Cut Solitaire Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Victorian .30 CTW 14 Karat Two-Stone Old Cushion Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,550.00
      Antique .74 CTW 14 Karat Old European Cut Diamond Vintage Three Stone Engagement Ring
      $1,650.00
      Antique .28 CTW 14 Karat Old European Cut Diamond Three Stone Engagement Ring
      $850.00
      Victorian .05 CTW 14 Karat Old Mine Cut Solitaire Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $895.00
      Mid-Century .62 CTW Platinum Old European Cut Diamond Three Stone Art Deco Engagement Ring
      $2,550.00
      Mid-Century .71 CTW 14 Karat Three Stone Marquise Baguette Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring GIA F/SI2
      $3,500.00
      Vintage .89 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Art Deco Engagement Ring GIA G/SI2
      $4,500.00
      Antique .49 CTW Geometric Square Old European Cut Diamond 14 Karat Art Deco Engagement Ring
      $1,950.00
      Antique .47 CTW Transitional Cut Diamond 18 Karat Art Deco Engagement Ring GIA L/SI2
      Antique .47 CTW Transitional Cut Diamond 18 Karat Art Deco Engagement Ring GIA L/SI2
      $2,250.00
      Art Deco .55 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Vintage Engagement Ring GIA F/VS1
      Art Deco .55 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Vintage Engagement Ring GIA F/VS1
      $3,250.00
      Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco .45 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Vintage Filigree Engagement Ring
      $3,000.00
      Mid-Century 1.56 CTW 18 Karat Round Cut Diamond Pave Set Vintage Engagement Ring GIA J/I1
      Mid-Century 1.56 CTW 18 Karat Round Cut Diamond Pave Set Vintage Engagement Ring GIA J/I1
      $3,350.00
      Mid-Century .97 CTW 14 Kt Three Stone Marquise Baguette Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring
      $4,000.00
      Art Deco .50 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Floral Vintage Engagement Ring GIA F/SI2
      $2,350.00
      Dainty Antique .05 CTW Old Single Cut Diamond 14 Karat Filigree Vintage Engagement Ring
      Dainty Antique .05 CTW Old Single Cut Diamond 14 Karat Filigree Vintage Engagement Ring
      $795.00
      Antique .74 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Three Stone Vintage Engagement Ring
      $3,250.00
      Art Deco 0.25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Filigree Solitaire Engagement Ring
      Art Deco 0.25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Filigree Solitaire Engagement Ring
      $1,500.00
      Mid-Century .55 CTW Diamond Platinum Three Stone Vintage Wedding Ring
      Mid-Century .85 CTW Diamond Platinum Three Stone Vintage Wedding Ring
      $3,000.00
      Art Deco Geometric Square Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
      $1,350.00
      Art Deco .20 CTW Geometric Square Vintage Engagement Ring
      Art Deco .20 CTW Geometric Square Vintage Engagement Ring
      $2,050.00
      Vintage Oval Cut Bloodstone Solitaire Halo Engagement Ring 1.50 Carat
      Vintage Oval Cut Bloodstone Solitaire Halo Engagement Ring 1.50 Carat
      $1,050.00
      Dainty Victorian 3 Stone Opal Wedding Ring
      $1,050.00
      Dainty .03 CTW Geometric Square 18 Karat Two Tone Vintage Engagement Ring
      Dainty .03 CTW Geometric Square 18 Karat Two Tone Vintage Engagement Ring
      $1,250.00
      Victorian Buttercup .10 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring
      $1,350.00
      Vintage Dainty Geometric Square Pearl Wedding Ring
      $1,250.00