7 Best Places to Propose on Martha's Vineyard

Home / VDR.com Blog

by Suzanne Sachs • 5 min read

THE BASICS --

Martha's Vineyard is full of perfect places to propose. Whether you and the person you love are enthusiasts for beaches, cliffs, carousels, gardens, bridges or good food and wine, there’s a beautiful spot to create a lifetime of memories. But where, exactly, should that most important question be asked? This guide describes some of the best places in Martha's Vineyard to ask that special person to marry you.

WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW--

In this guide we will explain the following:

• Romantic Locations in Martha's Vineyard for Outdoor Lovers
• Menemsha Beach
• Aquinnah Cliffs
• Edgartown Lighthouse
• South Beach - Katama
• Mytoi Japanese Garden
• At Home
• Budget-Friendly
• Best Places to Propose in Martha's Vineyard

Romantic Locations in Martha's Vineyard for Outdoor Lovers

1. Menemsha Beach

Known for its unforgettable sunsets, Menemsha Beach is a favorite for couples looking for a quiet, scenic proposal. Bring a picnic and watch the sky light up in pinks and golds as fishing boats glide by. The cozy, small-town vibe makes the experience even more intimate.

2. Aquinnah Cliffs

Dramatic and breathtaking, the Aquinnah Cliffs offer panoramic views of the Atlantic and vibrant clay formations. Propose at sunset for golden light and ocean breezes that make the moment unforgettable. It’s one of the island’s most iconic and awe-inspiring natural spots.

3. Edgartown Lighthouse

Nestled on a quiet beach, this charming white lighthouse offers a romantic seaside backdrop. Walk along the path at dusk for a private, peaceful proposal with harbor views. It's classic Martha’s Vineyard—coastal, historic, and full of charm.

4. South Beach - Katama

If you love the sound of crashing waves and wide open skies, South Beach is ideal. Choose a less crowded area and write your proposal in the sand, then celebrate with a walk along the surf. The beach’s raw beauty adds drama and heart.

5. Mytoi Japanese Garden

This hidden gem features winding paths, bridges, and serene koi ponds tucked within a peaceful woodland garden. It’s perfect for a quiet, thoughtful proposal away from the crowds. The blend of natural beauty and tranquil design sets a romantic tone.

6. At-Home

Sometimes the most heartfelt proposals happen right at home. On Martha’s Vineyard, set the mood with seaside-inspired décor, a candlelit dinner featuring fresh local seafood, and a playlist filled with songs that mean something to both of you. Add personal touches like shells, beach glass, or framed photos from your favorite island moments to create an atmosphere that feels romantic, intimate, and entirely your own.

7. Budget-Friendly

A romantic proposal doesn’t require a luxury budget. Martha’s Vineyard offers a wealth of scenic and meaningful spots that are just as unforgettable as any high-end venue. Stroll along Vineyard Haven Harbor at golden hour, watch wildlife together at Felix Neck Sanctuary, or pop the question on the quiet sands of Lobsterville Beach. Ride the Flying Horses Carousel for a touch of nostalgia, or share a sweet moment beneath the Ocean Park gazebo in Oak Bluffs. These charming, low-cost settings are perfect for creating heartfelt memories that will last a lifetime.

“Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."
— Chloe G verified buyer

Best Places to Propose in Martha's Vineyard

While it can be tempting to get wrapped up in elaborate proposal plans, sometimes the very best way to ask the question is a classic, heartfelt, on-one-knee moment. Whatever you and your soon-to-be fiance or fiancee enjoy, Martha's Vineyards has beautiful and memorable places to propose. Make one of these romantic locations your special place by proposing with the perfect vintage engagement ring.

It's Time!

Martha's Vineyard has so many beautiful places to propose—now it’s just about choosing the perfect one. Make the moment even more special with the perfect vintage ring—schedule a virtual appointment or email us to get 5% off when you purchase a ring and mention our Best Places to Propose in Martha's Vineyard blog.

Vintage Engagement Rings For Everyone:

No matter which era is your favorite, these time-honored rings have a rich history and individualized character and will continue to have a timeless beauty and elegant appeal that is part of a legacy to pass on to future generations.

Find The Perfect Engagement Ring:

Vintage rings are prized not only for their beauty but also for their exquisite attention to detailing and faceting. If you’re looking for a ring with a sense of glamour, sophistication and vintage charm, explore our collection of vintage engagement rings today!

Suzanne Sachs