Pros and Cons of Buying an Edwardian Engagement Ring
by Suzanne Sachs • 5 min read
THE BASICS --
An Edwardian engagement ring offers timeless elegance, detailed craftsmanship, and vintage charm, but it might not be the right choice for everyone. Weighing the pros and cons of this antique style can help you decide if an Edwardian ring aligns with your personal taste and values. From its romantic design to its historical significance, understanding what sets it apart is key to making the right decision.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW--
In this guide, we will explain the following:
- Consider Style First
- Pros Of Edwardian Engagement Rings
- History
- Timeless Value
- Distinctive Design
- Ethically Sourced
- Sustainable Settings
- Cons Of Edwardian Engagement Rings
- Understated Brilliance
- Antique Diamond Color
- Durability
- Care
- Matching Bands
Consider Style First
Before choosing an Edwardian ring, it’s important to think about the style and preferences of the person who will be wearing it. Edwardian era rings are known for their delicate filigree, milgrain detailing, and romantic, lacy designs—but they may not suit someone who prefers bold, contemporary styles. If your partner loves vintage elegance, intricate metalwork, and the grace of a bygone era, an Edwardian ring could be the perfect fit.
Pros of Edwardian Engagement Rings:
An Edwardian engagement ring offers more than just a beautiful design—it captures the grace, detail, and romance of a bygone era. It also offers…
• History
Edwardian rings have a rich history and lasting symbolism that reflect the elegance of the early 1900s. These rings may have already witnessed decades—perhaps over a century—of love and commitment, embodying the depth of relationships that endure. Even without knowing every detail of its past, the quiet mystery of an Edwardian ring adds a romantic allure as couples look ahead to their future together.
• Timeless Value
Edwardian rings, while antique, often offer exceptional value compared to modern designs. Because they are pre-owned, these rings can come at more accessible prices—especially when considering the size and quality of the gemstones and the intricacy of the craftsmanship. For couples seeking beauty, history, and detail without overspending, an Edwardian ring can be a meaningful and budget-friendly choice.
• Distinctive Design
Edwardian era rings were created during a time when expert jewelers handcrafted each piece with extraordinary care and artistry. Made before the era of mass production, these rings often feature delicate filigree, lace-like platinum work, and intricate settings that reflect the refined tastes of the early 20th century. Their one-of-a-kind craftsmanship makes them truly stand out from modern, machine-made designs.
• Ethically Sourced
For socially conscious couples, antique rings from the Edwardian era offer peace of mind when it comes to ethical sourcing. Since these rings were crafted long before the rise of conflict diamonds in the 1980s, their stones predate modern concerns tied to unethical mining practices. Choosing an Edwardian ring allows couples to embrace timeless beauty without contributing to today’s supply chain issues.
• Sustainable Settings
Rings from the Edwardian era are not only elegant but also an eco-friendly option for couples who care about sustainability. Because these antique pieces already exist, they avoid the environmental impact of new mining, manufacturing, and global shipping—processes that can lead to pollution, habitat destruction, and carbon emissions. Choosing an Edwardian ring means extending the life of a beautifully crafted heirloom without adding to today’s environmental footprint.
Cons of Edwardian Engagement Rings:
While they do have many benefits, it is equally important to consider the potential negative points before purchasing an Edwardian engagement ring, including…
• Understated Brilliance
Unlike modern diamonds, stones in antique rings from the Edwardian era were often cut by hand with fewer, larger facets. These old-cut diamonds may not have the intense brilliance of modern precision-cut stones, but they offer a softer, more romantic glow. Some stones may show gentle wear over time, but a professional cleaning can restore much of their natural beauty and charm.
• Antique Diamond Color
Diamonds in Edwardian engagement rings often feature warmer tones that were admired during the early 1900s. Unlike today’s preference for colorless stones, diamonds with subtle hints of yellow or champagne hues were common and even desirable in that era. While these stones may appear less “white” by modern standards, they reflect the authentic beauty and stylistic preferences of their time.
• Durability
Edwardian engagement rings have already proven their longevity, but their age and intricate designs can make them more delicate than modern pieces. Over time, settings may loosen or show signs of wear, especially in rings with fine filigree or milgrain detailing. While repairs may require the skill of an experienced jeweler, these timeless pieces can often be restored and reinforced to continue their journey for generations to come.
• Care
Vintage rings from the Edwardian era are known for their intricate filigree, delicate settings, and occasional use of multiple gemstones—all of which call for careful maintenance. Because of their age and craftsmanship, they’re often not suitable for ultrasonic cleaning, particularly if the metal is fragile or the stones vary in hardness. Gentle hand-cleaning and regular care can help preserve their original brilliance and keep their antique charm shining for generations.
• Matching Bands
Because Edwardian era rings are often uniquely crafted with intricate, flowing designs, finding a perfectly matching wedding band can be a challenge. Some couples choose to have a custom band made to fit the contours of the antique ring, while others embrace the individuality by wearing a complementary band instead. Another elegant option is to wear the engagement ring on the right hand after the ceremony and pair it with a vintage wedding band on the left.
Weighing the pros and cons of an Edwardian engagement ring can help you decide if this antique style is the right symbol for your relationship, but ultimately, the choice is deeply personal. These romantic rings reflect a unique blend of history, elegance, and craftsmanship that may align perfectly with your story. Finding a ring that speaks to your heart is a meaningful first step on the journey toward your future together.
ANTIQUE ENGAGEMENT RINGS FOR EVERYONE:
No matter which era is your favorite, these time-honored rings have a rich history and individualized character and will continue to have a timeless beauty and elegant appeal that is part of a legacy to pass on to future generations.
FIND THE PERFECT ENGAGEMENT RING:
Antique diamond cuts are prized not only for their beauty but also for their exquisite attention to detailing and faceting. If you’re looking for a ring with a sense of glamour, sophistication and vintage charm, explore our collection of vintage engagement rings today!
SUZANNE SACHS
Press Love:
Contact Suzanne
If you love vintage jewelry please feel free to contact Suzanne or browse our collection of vintage engagment rings.
Leave a comment