Engagement Rings Under $2,500
Vintage engagement rings under $2,500 feature hand-cut Old Mine and Old European diamonds set within the craftsmanship of their era. From the romantic detail of the Victorian period to the refined geometry of Art Deco design, each ring reflects a distinct moment in jewelry history—and a lifetime of character—at an accessible price point.
805 products
Emmy Lou: .35 Ct Square Cut Colombian Emerald Mid-Century Ring (1970s)
Emmy Lou: .35 Ct Square Cut Colombian Emerald Mid-Century Ring (1970s)
Antique Ruby & Old European Cut Diamond Three Stone Engagement Ring — .50 CTW, 18K White Gold
Antique Ruby & Old European Cut Diamond Three Stone Engagement Ring — .50 CTW, 18K White Gold
Art Deco Toi et Moi .68 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Sapphire Two Stone Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco Toi et Moi .68 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Sapphire Two Stone Antique Engagement Ring
Vintage Channel Set Pink Sapphire Wedding Ring
Vintage Channel Set Pink Sapphire Wedding Ring
Victorian .40 CTW Garnet & Rose Cut Diamond Gemstone Engagement Ring
Victorian .40 CTW Garnet & Rose Cut Diamond Gemstone Engagement Ring
Art Deco .25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring with Sapphire Accents
Art Deco .25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring with Sapphire Accents
Vintage 1.25 Carat Heart Shape Citrine Pendant
Vintage 1.25 Carat Heart Shape Citrine Pendant
Art Deco 1.75ct Emerald Cut Aquamarine Halo Engagement Ring | 14k White Gold Filigree Ring
Art Deco 1.75ct Emerald Cut Aquamarine Halo Engagement Ring | 14k White Gold Filigree Ring
Art Deco North-South 1.50 CTW 10 Karat White Gold Citrine Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco North-South 1.50 CTW 10 Karat White Gold Citrine Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco 1.50 CTW Emerald Cut Citrine Engagement Ring
Art Deco 1.50 CTW Emerald Cut Citrine Engagement Ring
Mid-Century Blue Zircon .90 CTW 14 Karat Rose Gold Gemstone Ring
Mid-Century Blue Zircon .90 CTW 14 Karat Rose Gold Gemstone Ring
Victorian Seed Pearl Starburst Engagement Ring in 10K Rose Gold
Victorian Seed Pearl Starburst Engagement Ring in 10K Rose Gold
Victorian .20 CTW Amethyst Spinel Pearl Antique Engagement Ring
Victorian .20 CTW Amethyst Spinel Pearl Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco 2.75 CTW Rectangular Cut Antique Aquamarine Engagement Ring
Art Deco 2.75 CTW Rectangular Cut Antique Aquamarine Engagement Ring
Art Deco .50 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring
Art Deco .50 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring
Victorian Turquoise & Pearl Antique Engagement Ring
Victorian Turquoise & Pearl Antique Engagement Ring
Antique Bezel Set 5.00 CTW Amethyst Pearl Halo Vintage Engagement Ring
Antique Bezel Set 5.00 CTW Amethyst Pearl Halo Vintage Engagement Ring
Vintage Synthetic Pink Gemstone Cocktail Ring
Vintage Synthetic Pink Gemstone Cocktail Ring
Mid-Century 7.00 CTW Synthetic Blue Gemstone 14 Karat Two Tone Vintage Cocktail Ring
Mid-Century 7.00 CTW Synthetic Blue Gemstone 14 Karat Two Tone Vintage Cocktail Ring
Art Deco 1.50 Ct Emerald Cut Aquamarine Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco 1.50 Ct Emerald Cut Aquamarine Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco .30 CTW Old European Cut Diamond & Sapphire Antique Engagement Ring in 14 Kt White Gold
Art Deco .30 CTW Old European Cut Diamond & Sapphire Antique Engagement Ring in 14 Kt White Gold
Victorian .75 CT Purple Tourmaline and Pearl Engagement Ring | Antique Rose Gold
Victorian .75 CT Purple Tourmaline and Pearl Engagement Ring | Antique Rose Gold
Vintage Square Cut Citrine Engagement Ring 2.70 Ct
Vintage Square Cut Citrine Engagement Ring 2.70 Ct
Art Deco 2.20 Ct Emerald Cut Aquamarine Vintage Engagement Ring
Art Deco 2.20 Ct Emerald Cut Aquamarine Vintage Engagement Ring
Customer Reviews
Excellent!
"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."
Claude P - verified buyer
Source
Great Service!
"I've purchased two vintage rings from Suzanne over the past decade and my wife has loved both. Great service, communication and speedy delivery."
Lee S - verified buyer
Amazing!
"Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."
Chloe G - verified buyer
Excellent!
