What makes an engagement ring non-traditional?

A non-traditional engagement ring steps outside the classic diamond solitaire to embrace colored gemstones, unconventional settings, or distinctive vintage designs. In authentic vintage jewelry this might mean a Kashmir sapphire in an Art Deco platinum setting, a Burma ruby surrounded by Old European cut diamonds, or a delicate Victorian pearl ring in yellow gold. What defines a non-traditional ring is individuality — a piece that reflects personal style rather than convention.

Are non-traditional engagement rings becoming more popular?

Yes — and vintage non-traditional rings in particular have seen significant growth in popularity. Couples increasingly want something genuinely one of a kind rather than a mass-produced diamond ring. Colored gemstone rings from the Victorian, Edwardian and Art Deco eras offer extraordinary craftsmanship, real history, and a depth of character that modern rings simply cannot replicate.

What are the best gemstones for a non-traditional engagement ring?

The most popular choices for non-traditional engagement rings are sapphires, rubies, and emeralds — prized for their rarity, color depth, and durability. Aquamarines, garnets, amethysts, and natural pearls are also beautiful options. In vintage settings these stones appear in Victorian yellow gold, Edwardian platinum filigree, and bold Art Deco geometric designs — each combination creating something entirely unique.

Non-Traditional Engagement Rings | Vintage Gemstone Colored Stone Rings- Page 5| Vintage Diamond Ring

Non-traditional engagement rings are defined by originality, blending unusual gemstones, distinctive settings, and authentic vintage design. From richly colored stones to intricate details of the Victorian, Art Deco, and Edwardian eras, each ring carries its own history and character. Every piece in this collection is truly one of a kind.

Filter

254 products

Clear all

Filter

Previous Page 1 … 3 4 5 6 7 … 11 Next Page

Non-Traditional Engagement Rings FAQ's

Customer Reviews

Excellent!

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Claude P - verified buyer

Source

Great Service!

"I've purchased two vintage rings from Suzanne over the past decade and my wife has loved both. Great service, communication and speedy delivery."

Lee S - verified buyer

Amazing!

"Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."

Chloe G - verified buyer

Excellent!

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Customer name

View More Reviews

Non-Traditional Engagement Rings

Filter

Victorian 5 Stone Opal Wedding Ring in Rosy Yellow Gold

Art Deco 3.00 CTW Rectangular Cut Antique Citrine Engagement Ring

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Wedding Ring | 1920s

Art Deco 1.00 CTW Round Cut Peridot Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring

Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring 1.83 CT Platinum GIA K/I1 Circa 1930s

Victorian .35 CTW Sapphire & Rose Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring in Rosy Yellow Gold

Art Deco Cushion Cut Bloodstone Solitaire Engagement Ring 1.50 Ct

Vintage 1.55 CTW Moonstone & Diamond Gemstone Engagement Ring

Victorian .60 CTW Opal Garnet Vintage Gemstone Engagement Ring

Art Deco 1.50 CTW Bullet Shape Shield Cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring

Vintage 3 Stone 14 Karat White Gold .30 CTW Art Deco Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring

Antique .45 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring

Victorian Opal & Pearl Engagement Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900

Victorian 1.25 CTW Rectangular Cut Purple Garnet Antique Gemstone Engagement Ring

Vintage 1.55 Carat Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Baguette and Round Diamonds

Mid-Century 4.00 CTW Round Cut Aquamarine and Diamond Pave Vintage Engagement Ring

Vintage 2.50 Carat Round Amethyst Engagement Ring

Vintage Pear Shape Amethyst & Baguette Diamond Engagement Ring | Yellow Gold | 1970s

Vintage Round Cut Amethyst and Diamond Engagement Ring

Vintage Split Shank Amethyst & Diamond Engagement Ring

Victorian 1.20 CTW Twin Moonstone and Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Victorian Style .81 CTW 18 Karat Two Tone Burma Ruby Engagement Ring

Samina | 1940s Vintage .75 CT Emerald Cut Garnet Ring

Vintage Bezel Set 1.25 CTW Square Cut 10 Karat Rose Gold Aquamarine Solitaire Gemstone Engagement Ring

Non-Traditional Engagement Rings FAQ's

Customer Reviews

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Claude P - verified buyer

"I've purchased two vintage rings from Suzanne over the past decade and my wife has loved both. Great service, communication and speedy delivery."

Lee S - verified buyer

"Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."

Chloe G - verified buyer

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Customer name

Search

Recent searches

Main menu

Non-Traditional Engagement Rings

Filter

Victorian 5 Stone Opal Wedding Ring in Rosy Yellow Gold

Art Deco 3.00 CTW Rectangular Cut Antique Citrine Engagement Ring

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Wedding Ring | 1920s

Art Deco 1.00 CTW Round Cut Peridot Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring

Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring 1.83 CT Platinum GIA K/I1 Circa 1930s

Victorian .35 CTW Sapphire & Rose Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring in Rosy Yellow Gold

Art Deco Cushion Cut Bloodstone Solitaire Engagement Ring 1.50 Ct

Vintage 1.55 CTW Moonstone & Diamond Gemstone Engagement Ring

Victorian .60 CTW Opal Garnet Vintage Gemstone Engagement Ring

Art Deco 1.50 CTW Bullet Shape Shield Cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring

Vintage 3 Stone 14 Karat White Gold .30 CTW Art Deco Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring

Antique .45 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond & Sapphire Engagement Ring

Victorian Opal & Pearl Engagement Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900

Victorian 1.25 CTW Rectangular Cut Purple Garnet Antique Gemstone Engagement Ring

Vintage 1.55 Carat Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Baguette and Round Diamonds

Mid-Century 4.00 CTW Round Cut Aquamarine and Diamond Pave Vintage Engagement Ring

Vintage 2.50 Carat Round Amethyst Engagement Ring

Vintage Pear Shape Amethyst & Baguette Diamond Engagement Ring | Yellow Gold | 1970s

Vintage Round Cut Amethyst and Diamond Engagement Ring

Vintage Split Shank Amethyst & Diamond Engagement Ring

Victorian 1.20 CTW Twin Moonstone and Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Victorian Style .81 CTW 18 Karat Two Tone Burma Ruby Engagement Ring

Samina | 1940s Vintage .75 CT Emerald Cut Garnet Ring

Vintage Bezel Set 1.25 CTW Square Cut 10 Karat Rose Gold Aquamarine Solitaire Gemstone Engagement Ring

Non-Traditional Engagement Rings FAQ's

Customer Reviews

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Claude P - verified buyer

"I've purchased two vintage rings from Suzanne over the past decade and my wife has loved both. Great service, communication and speedy delivery."

Lee S - verified buyer

"Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."

Chloe G - verified buyer

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Customer name

Be the first to know! Join our mailing list.

Search

Recent searches

Main menu