Skip to content
5 Star Reviews
  1. FREE OVERNIGHT SHIPPING AND SIZING + FREE 30 DAY RETURNS
  2. 1 YEAR LAYAWAY WITH 5 % DOWN + 0% APR FOR 6 MONTHS WITH AFFIRM

 877-321-3326

 suzane@vintagediamondring.com

https://vintagediamondring.com/collections/sustainable-engagement-rings-under-2-500

Sustainable Engagement Rings Under $2,500.00

Filter

842 products

Clear all
Vintage Trefoil Prong Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Stones

Vintage Trefoil Prong Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Stones

$1,450.00
Vintage Trefoil Prong Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Stones
Vintage Trefoil Prong Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Stones
Vintage Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Baguette and Princess Cut Diamonds

Contemporary 2.10 CTW Aquamarine Engagement Ring Baguette Princess Cut Diamonds

$2,150.00
Contemporary 2.10 CTW Aquamarine Engagement Ring Baguette Princess Cut Diamonds
Contemporary 2.10 CTW Aquamarine Engagement Ring Baguette Princess Cut Diamonds
Vintage 1.55 Carat Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Baguette and Round Diamonds

Vintage 1.55 Carat Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Baguette and Round Diamonds

$1,950.00
Vintage 1.55 Carat Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Baguette and Round Diamonds
Vintage 1.55 Carat Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Side Baguette and Round Diamonds

Art Deco Geometric Square Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

$1,450.00
Art Deco Geometric Square Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Art Deco Geometric Square Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Art Deco .20 CTW Geometric Square Vintage Engagement Ring

Art Deco .25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Geometric Square Vintage Engagement Ring in 18K White Gold

$2,050.00
Art Deco .25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Geometric Square Vintage Engagement Ring in 18K White Gold
Art Deco .25 Ct Old European Cut Diamond Geometric Square Vintage Engagement Ring in 18K White Gold
Antique .55 CTW Bezel Set Rectangular Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring - Vintage Diamond Ring

Antique .55 CTW Bezel Set Rectangular Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring

$1,850.00
Antique .55 CTW Bezel Set Rectangular Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring
Antique .55 CTW Bezel Set Rectangular Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring
Art Deco .35 CT Old European Cut Diamond Engraved Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring

Art Deco .35 CT Old European Cut Diamond Engraved Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring

$1,850.00
Art Deco .35 CT Old European Cut Diamond Engraved Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring
Art Deco .35 CT Old European Cut Diamond Engraved Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring
Mid Century Marquis Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1.19 Carat

Mid-Century Marquis Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1.19 Carat GIA F/I3

$1,250.00
Mid-Century Marquis Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1.19 Carat GIA F/I3
Mid-Century Marquis Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1.19 Carat GIA F/I3
Vintage Geometric Square Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring .30 Ct G/SI2

Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 18K White Gold | 1930s

$2,350.00
Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 18K White Gold | 1930s
Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 18K White Gold | 1930s

Art Deco .29 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring Intricate Open Metalwork

$2,250.00
Art Deco .29 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring Intricate Open Metalwork
Art Deco .29 CTW Old European Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring Intricate Open Metalwork

Vintage Geometric Square .43 CTW European Cut Art Deco Engagement Ring

$2,050.00
Vintage Geometric Square .43 CTW European Cut Art Deco Engagement Ring
Vintage Geometric Square .43 CTW European Cut Art Deco Engagement Ring
Art Deco .40 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring

Art Deco .40 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring

$2,050.00
Art Deco .40 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring
Art Deco .40 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Vintage Engagement Ring
Dainty Victorian three-stone opal wedding ring in yellow gold

Dainty Victorian 3 Stone Opal Wedding Ring

$1,250.00
Dainty Victorian 3 Stone Opal Wedding Ring
Dainty Victorian 3 Stone Opal Wedding Ring
Dainty .03 CTW Geometric Square 18 Karat Two Tone Vintage Engagement Ring

Dainty .03 CTW Geometric Square 18 Karat Two Tone Vintage Engagement Ring

$1,250.00
Dainty .03 CTW Geometric Square 18 Karat Two Tone Vintage Engagement Ring
Dainty .03 CTW Geometric Square 18 Karat Two Tone Vintage Engagement Ring
Victorian buttercup engagement ring featuring a .10 carat old mine cut diamond in a yellow gold setting

Victorian .10 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring in 10K Rosy Yellow Gold

$1,350.00
Victorian .10 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring in 10K Rosy Yellow Gold
Victorian .10 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring in 10K Rosy Yellow Gold

Vintage Dainty Geometric Square Pearl Wedding Ring

$1,250.00
Vintage Dainty Geometric Square Pearl Wedding Ring
Vintage Dainty Geometric Square Pearl Wedding Ring

1.50 Carat Art Deco Lozenge Shape Citrine Engagement Ring

$1,750.00
1.50 Carat Art Deco Lozenge Shape Citrine Engagement Ring
1.50 Carat Art Deco Lozenge Shape Citrine Engagement Ring

3.00 Carat Art Deco Oval Cut Citrine Engagement Ring

$2,250.00
3.00 Carat Art Deco Oval Cut Citrine Engagement Ring
3.00 Carat Art Deco Oval Cut Citrine Engagement Ring
Mid-Century 2.00 CTW Colored Semi-Precious Gemstone Vintaqge Cocktail Ring

Vintage Multi-Gemstone Cocktail Ring in Yellow Gold | 1980s

$2,050.00
Vintage Multi-Gemstone Cocktail Ring in Yellow Gold | 1980s
Vintage Multi-Gemstone Cocktail Ring in Yellow Gold | 1980s
Victorian Opal & Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Kt Rose Gold Front View

Victorian Opal & Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Kt Rose Gold

$2,250.00
Victorian Opal & Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Kt Rose Gold
Victorian Opal & Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Kt Rose Gold
Dainty Victorian starburst wedding ring featuring turquoise and pearl accents with filigree in 10K rose gold

Victorian Pearl & Turquoise Starburst Wedding Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900

$1,450.00
Victorian Pearl & Turquoise Starburst Wedding Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900
Victorian Pearl & Turquoise Starburst Wedding Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900
Victorian garnet starburst engagement ring in rose gold with filigree engravings, circa 1900s

Victorian Garnet Starburst Rose Gold Engagement Ring Circa 1900s

$1,450.00
Victorian Garnet Starburst Rose Gold Engagement Ring Circa 1900s
Victorian Garnet Starburst Rose Gold Engagement Ring Circa 1900s
Art Deco .15 CTW Old European Cut Antique Engagement Ring with Open Metal Work

Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring .15 Ct Open Metalwork 18K White Gold

$1,500.00
Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring .15 Ct Open Metalwork 18K White Gold
Art Deco Old European Cut Diamond Antique Engagement Ring .15 Ct Open Metalwork 18K White Gold
Victorian old mine cut diamond solitaire engagement ring with antique metalwork and a .07 carat center stone

Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring | 10K Gold

$1,050.00
Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring | 10K Gold
Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring | 10K Gold

Customer Reviews

Excellent!

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Claude P - verified buyer

Source

Great Service!

"I've purchased two vintage rings from Suzanne over the past decade and my wife has loved both. Great service, communication and speedy delivery."

Lee S - verified buyer

Amazing!

"Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."

Chloe G - verified buyer

Excellent!

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Customer name

View More Reviews

Search

Main menu

Shopping Bag

Your shopping bag is empty. Still thinking about something beautiful? Continue exploring our collection — or contact us anytime at suzane@vintagediamondring.com or 877-321-3326.

Shop now