Skip to content
5 Star Reviews
  1. FREE OVERNIGHT SHIPPING AND SIZING + FREE 30 DAY RETURNS
  2. 1 YEAR LAYAWAY WITH 5 % DOWN + 0% APR FOR 6 MONTHS WITH AFFIRM

 877-321-3326

 suzane@vintagediamondring.com

https://vintagediamondring.com/collections/sustainable-engagement-rings-under-2-500

Sustainable Engagement Rings Under $2,500.00

Filter

842 products

Clear all

Antique Diamond Engagement Ring .60ct Old Mine Cut 14K White Gold Filigree

$2,350.00
Antique Diamond Engagement Ring .60ct Old Mine Cut 14K White Gold Filigree
Antique Diamond Engagement Ring .60ct Old Mine Cut 14K White Gold Filigree

Art Deco .20 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | J VS2 18k White Gold Square Milgrain

$1,650.00
Art Deco .20 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | J VS2 18k White Gold Square Milgrain
Art Deco .20 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | J VS2 18k White Gold Square Milgrain

Vintage 1950s .70ct Transitional Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | AGI H SI2 14k White Gold Fishtail Setting

$1,950.00
Vintage 1950s .70ct Transitional Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | AGI H SI2 14k White Gold Fishtail Setting
Vintage 1950s .70ct Transitional Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | AGI H SI2 14k White Gold Fishtail Setting

Mid-Century .90 CTW Two-Row Diamond Wedding Band | 14K Two-Tone Gold

$2,250.00
Mid-Century .90 CTW Two-Row Diamond Wedding Band | 14K Two-Tone Gold
Mid-Century .90 CTW Two-Row Diamond Wedding Band | 14K Two-Tone Gold

Mid-Century Toi et Moi Diamond Engagement Ring | .30 CTW, Two-Tone Gold

$1,450.00
Mid-Century Toi et Moi Diamond Engagement Ring | .30 CTW, Two-Tone Gold
Mid-Century Toi et Moi Diamond Engagement Ring | .30 CTW, Two-Tone Gold

Belais Art Deco .40 Ct Old European Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring, 18K White Gold

$2,050.00
Belais Art Deco .40 Ct Old European Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring, 18K White Gold
Belais Art Deco .40 Ct Old European Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring, 18K White Gold

Antique .15 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Art Deco Engagement Ring

$1,450.00
Antique .15 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Art Deco Engagement Ring
Antique .15 CTW Old European Cut Diamond 18 Karat White Gold Art Deco Engagement Ring

Art Deco Emerald Cut Garnet Engagement Ring — 1.50 ct, 14 Karat White Gold

$1,850.00
Art Deco Emerald Cut Garnet Engagement Ring — 1.50 ct, 14 Karat White Gold
Art Deco Emerald Cut Garnet Engagement Ring — 1.50 ct, 14 Karat White Gold
Victorian Three Stone Bezel Set Sapphire & Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in Platinum and 14 Karat Yellow Gold Front View

Victorian Bezel-Set Sapphire & Old European Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum & 14K Yellow Gold

$1,750.00
Victorian Bezel-Set Sapphire & Old European Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum & 14K Yellow Gold
Victorian Bezel-Set Sapphire & Old European Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum & 14K Yellow Gold

  • On Sale

Victorian .35 CTW Mine Cut Diamond Halo 10 Karat Rose Gold Antique Engagement Ring Front View

Victorian Ruby & Old Mine Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900

$2,000.00 $2,250.00
Victorian Ruby & Old Mine Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900

  • On Sale

Victorian Ruby & Old Mine Cut Diamond Halo Engagement Ring in Rose Gold | Circa 1900
Art Deco .51 CTW Solitaire Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring GIA J/VS2 - Vintage Diamond Ring

Art Deco .51 CTW Solitaire Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring GIA J/VS2

$2,250.00
Art Deco .51 CTW Solitaire Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring GIA J/VS2
Art Deco .51 CTW Solitaire Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring GIA J/VS2
Antique .47 CTW Transitional Cut Diamond 18 Karat Art Deco Engagement Ring GIA L/SI2

Art Deco .47ct Transitional Cut Diamond 18K White Gold GIA Engagement Ring

$2,250.00
Art Deco .47ct Transitional Cut Diamond 18K White Gold GIA Engagement Ring
Art Deco .47ct Transitional Cut Diamond 18K White Gold GIA Engagement Ring
Victorian .60 CTW Pink Sapphire & Seed Pearl Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold Front Photo

Victorian Pink Sapphire Engagement Ring with Seed Pearls in 10K Rose Gold

$1,850.00
Victorian Pink Sapphire Engagement Ring with Seed Pearls in 10K Rose Gold
Victorian Pink Sapphire Engagement Ring with Seed Pearls in 10K Rose Gold

Antique Sapphire & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

$1,850.00
Antique Sapphire & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Antique Sapphire & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Front view of vintage opal engagement ring with 1 carat cabochon opal and transitional cut diamonds in 14K yellow gold

Vintage Opal Engagement Ring with Transitional Cut Diamonds in 14K Yellow Gold

$1,950.00
Vintage Opal Engagement Ring with Transitional Cut Diamonds in 14K Yellow Gold
Vintage Opal Engagement Ring with Transitional Cut Diamonds in 14K Yellow Gold
Victorian toi et moi engagement ring with natural cat’s eye chrysoberyl and seed pearls in 10K rose gold

Victorian Toi et Moi Natural Cat’s Eye Chrysoberyl & Pearl Engagement Ring – 10K Rose Gold

$1,500.00
Victorian Toi et Moi Natural Cat’s Eye Chrysoberyl & Pearl Engagement Ring – 10K Rose Gold
Victorian Toi et Moi Natural Cat’s Eye Chrysoberyl & Pearl Engagement Ring – 10K Rose Gold

  • On Sale

Art Deco emerald cut amethyst engagement ring in 18K white gold with filigree

Art Deco 2.50 CT Emerald-Cut Amethyst Engagement Ring | 18K White Gold

$1,550.00 $1,850.00
Art Deco 2.50 CT Emerald-Cut Amethyst Engagement Ring | 18K White Gold

  • On Sale

Art Deco 2.50 CT Emerald-Cut Amethyst Engagement Ring | 18K White Gold
victorian rose cut diamond and green garnet doublet engagement ring in 10k rose gold front view

Victorian Green Garnet Doublet & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold

$1,450.00
Victorian Green Garnet Doublet & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
Victorian Green Garnet Doublet & Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
victorian old mine cut amethyst and seed pearl engagement ring in 10k rose gold front view

Victorian Amethyst and Seed Pearl Wedding Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold

$1,450.00
Victorian Amethyst and Seed Pearl Wedding Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
Victorian Amethyst and Seed Pearl Wedding Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
victorian turquoise and paste wedding ring in 10k rose gold with filigree front view

Victorian Turquoise Paste Wedding Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold

$1,650.00
Victorian Turquoise Paste Wedding Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
Victorian Turquoise Paste Wedding Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
victorian opal engagement ring with six cabochon opals in 10k rose gold

Victorian Opal Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold

$1,350.00
Victorian Opal Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
Victorian Opal Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
Victorian 1.01 ct cushion cut peridot solitaire engagement ring in 10k rose gold

Victorian 1.01 CTW Oval Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold

$1,850.00
Victorian 1.01 CTW Oval Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold
Victorian 1.01 CTW Oval Peridot Solitaire Engagement Ring in 10 Karat Rose Gold

Retro Turquoise & Rose Cut Diamond Ring | 14K Rose Gold | 1940s

$2,250.00
Retro Turquoise & Rose Cut Diamond Ring | 14K Rose Gold | 1940s
Retro Turquoise & Rose Cut Diamond Ring | 14K Rose Gold | 1940s

Georgian Rose Cut Diamond Flower Engagement Ring in Silver and 10 Karat Rose Gold

$1,750.00
Georgian Rose Cut Diamond Flower Engagement Ring in Silver and 10 Karat Rose Gold
Georgian Rose Cut Diamond Flower Engagement Ring in Silver and 10 Karat Rose Gold

Customer Reviews

Excellent!

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Claude P - verified buyer

Source

Great Service!

"I've purchased two vintage rings from Suzanne over the past decade and my wife has loved both. Great service, communication and speedy delivery."

Lee S - verified buyer

Amazing!

"Suzanne was amazing! I utilized the layaway service and it was a breeze. Ring made its way to Texas and was even more gorgeous in person."

Chloe G - verified buyer

Excellent!

"My experience with Vintage Diamond Ring was so excellent I really had to think about it for a while. First their selection of jewelry is profound. The quality is superior."

Customer name

View More Reviews

Search

Main menu

Shopping Bag

Your shopping bag is empty. Still thinking about something beautiful? Continue exploring our collection — or contact us anytime at suzane@vintagediamondring.com or 877-321-3326.

Shop now