How to Choose the Perfect Antique Engagement Ring

Home — VDR.com Blog

by Suzanne Sachs — 5 min read

THE BASICS ---

An antique engagement ring can be the perfect choice to showcase the vows you and your beloved have pledged to share. But which ring is best for your individual style and will best match the significance and symbolism of your unique relationship?

WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW---

In this guide, we will explain the following:

• What is an Antique Engagement Ring?
• Choosing Your Perfect Antique Engagement Ring
• Authentication is Key

What Is an Antique Engagement Ring?

First of all, it is important to understand that not every "old" ring is necessarily an actual antique piece. In general, jewelers consider an item authentically antique if it is roughly 100 years old or older, though there is some small leeway for a jewelry era. For example, the Art Deco jewelry era extended from mid-to late-1910s and into the 1930s. Today, any piece of Art Deco jewelry would likely be considered antique, even if it might only be 85-90 years old rather than having already reached the century mark.

The condition and workmanship of antique rings can vary dramatically. Because these rings were produced prior to machine crafting, their individual artistry depends on the skill and expertise of the jeweler creating the piece. This does give antique engagement rings inimitable character and one-of-a-kind distinction unmatched by modern rings, but couples should not expect modern, laser-like precision in antique workmanship.

It is important to realize, however, that an antique ring can have some controversy as to its authenticity. While updates to the ring — resizing, repairs, or even replacing the center stone — are to be expected after so many years, any dramatic changes that completely restyle the piece might cause it to lose its antique status.

Choosing Your Perfect Antique Engagement Ring

If you believe an antique ring may be the perfect way to mark your engagement, it is important to first study different antique jewelry eras to learn the traits they showcase and determine which styles most appeal to you. There are very distinct design changes between Edwardian, Victorian, Art Deco, and other eras, and being able to recognize them can help you better appreciate their individual symbolism and beauty. Consider the culture and romance of each era and what design elements you like best in order to choose the antique engagement ring you can love for many years.

Next, try on a variety of rings from your chosen era. Even within a single jewelry design era, there can be very different styles from early in the era when compared to the end of the era when the fashion flair is more well-defined. Also try on rings of different overall sizes – larger, more elaborate rings as well as smaller, more delicate designs – to decide which style you prefer. Consider how each type looks on your finger to be sure it doesn’t appear too small or too large, and note how it feels when resting on your hand with your fingers in different positions.

Consider whether you are interested in a stand-alone engagement ring or prefer a matching set with a coordinating wedding ring. If your antique engagement ring does not already have a matching wedding ring, it can be very difficult to match the style for a smooth, blended look. Because many antique styles may not have straight edges, it can be tough to find a wedding ring or band that will fit snuggly against an antique engagement ring without causing damage or scratches. There are antique engagement and wedding ring sets, however, that can be beautiful choices.

Finally, consider the overall price of an antique engagement ring. While older rings have great price variance just like any piece of jewelry based on quality, gemstones, and overall condition, antique engagement rings have other costs to consider. An antique ring may need repair, resizing, or resetting stones before it can be worn, or it may need extensive cleaning to ensure it looks its best. Because antique rings require special care, this type of work may need to be done by an antique jewelry expert and can be more costly than with a new ring. Those overall costs should be factored in to a couple’s total engagement ring budget.

Authentication Is Key

When you are ready to buy an antique engagement ring, the proper provenance – history — for the ring is essential. This should include ownership records, details on repairs and maintenance over the years, and as much individual history as possible such as inspections, inheritances, estates sales, and more. This documentation will help verify the ring's authenticity, which will help with proper valuation and insurance purposes.

While a reputable jeweler will provide as much of this documentation as possible, arranging an independent appraisal of the piece can also be useful. Extra eyes can also reveal any possible additional issues with the ring that would need to be addressed before it’s ready for that most important question.

Antique engagement rings can be a stunning expression of love and commitment between a couple, but it is necessary to be thorough when learning more about these rings and whether one is right for your relationship. When you’re ready, the perfect antique engagement ring can be the perfect way to propose to that perfect someone. Explore our collection of antique engagement rings and discover a timeless piece that reflects your unique love story. Start browsing today to discover the perfect ring for your special moment.

Suzanne Sachs

Suzanne has always believed vintage rings can change lives. She's been in the jewelry industry for over 35 years, working with vintage jewelers, diamond dealers, diamond cutters, and gemologists. Suzanne started Artdecodiamonds in 2000 and understood the demand for vintage rings throughout the world. She ultimately started VintageDiamondRing.com in 2014, and understands each vintage ring is a reflection of you – your history, your relationships, your style, your elegance and is honored to have the opportunity to help you showcase your flair in a unique and exquisite way.